Menu of Chitterchats in Reedville, Virginia, USA

Menu Overview

Chitterchats, nestled in the charming town of Reedville, VA, offers a delightful ice cream experience that captivates both locals and visitors. This quaint ice cream shop stands out due to its dedication to craftsmanship and quality, with highlights such as the Banana Split, Mint Chip in a Cup, and Mint Chip in a Waffle Cone.

The Banana Split is a true crowd-pleaser—rich, creamy scoops paired perfectly with fresh banana slices and classic toppings. It embodies a nostalgic indulgence that feels both timeless and fresh. Fans like Victoria Tuthill praise it as the best in the region, emphasizing not only its taste but also the joy it brings to families visiting this beautiful town.

The Mint Chip flavors, available in both cups and freshly made waffle cones, showcase Chitterchats' commitment to quality ingredients and texture. The mint’s bright, refreshing flavor harmonizes with bursts of chocolate chips, delivering a perfect balance. The waffle cones, crafted on-site, add a memorable aroma and crispness that elevates the experience. While overwhelmingly loved, some customers like Elizabeth Steinruck noted the cone's thinness can cause messiness, an area where slight improvements could enhance user satisfaction.

Chitterchats’ ice cream texture stands out for its consistency and creaminess. Ryan Nicholson highlighted the near-perfect vanilla flavor and the impressive execution of their coffee ice cream shake, which maintains a luscious thickness without being overpowering. Similarly, the Family Parsons appreciated the quality, although they wished for a bit larger serving sizes given the price point.

The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and the intimacy of a small menu featuring about a dozen carefully curated flavors ensure every scoop is made with intent. Whether you’re grabbing a classic Banana Split, savoring the fresh mint chip in a waffle cone, or enjoying a thick milkshake, Chitterchats delivers an authentic ice cream delight that feels like a refined taste of a coastal town’s charm.

Located at 846 Main St, Chitterchats requires some planning due to its limited hours, but the payoff is worth it. For anyone exploring the scenic surroundings of Reedville or cruising Chesapeake Bay, stopping here is more than a treat—it’s a highlight of the visit.